In the summer of 1953, Dmitri Shostakovich (1906–1975) was working on his Tenth Symphony, eight years after he had written his Ninth, and he completed it that October. This was at a time when he had made several trips to visit Western countries that exposed him to diverse opinions. In March 1949, he was a member of a Soviet delegation sent to New York for a “Cultural and Scientific Conference for World Peace”. Before his departure for America, he received a telegram of support from leading musicians who were Americans or were working in the United States. It was signed by Bruno Walter, Serge Koussevitzky, Aaron Copland, and Leonard Bernstein as well as by Samuel Barber, whom Shostakovich was able to meet in person at a conference. In February 1951 he was elected a deputy of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR, and over the next two years he attended peace congresses in Warsaw and Vienna. All the while, his feelings became increasingly conflicted. Stalin died on 5 March 1953, and Izvestia and the journal Sovetskaya muzyka published articles under Shostakovich’s name calling for unity. At the same time, however, the composer was trying to come to terms with the Stalin era, not least through his music. While spending the summer at his dacha in Komarovo, he wrote to his pupil Kara Karayev: “I’m trying to write a symphony, and although no one is interrupting my work, it’s going slowly... I’m struggling with the first movement, and I don’t know how it will go after that.”
The gloomy themes of the first movement intertwine and overlap, and the central section rises to a huge climax of roaring chords, but the gloom remains unresolved. The second movement is a scherzo filled with sarcasm. Its principal theme is derived from material associated with the Prologue to Mussorgskyʼs Boris Godunov, which, in the year of Stalinʼs death, carried for Shostakovich associations of autocratic power exercised in the name of the people. In Shostakovich’s alleged “memoirs” published by Solomon Volkov, the composer is said to have commented as follows about the creation of his symphony: “I wrote it right after Stalinʼs death and no one has yet guessed what the symphony is about. Itʼs about Stalin and the Stalin years. The second part, the scherzo, is a musical portrait of Stalin, roughly speaking. Of course, there are many other things in it, but thatʼs the basis.” In all four movements, Shostakovich employs the notes d / e flat / c / b natural, which, when spelled in the central European manner as D / Es / C / H, represent the composer’s initials “D Sch”, a musical signature most prominently heard in the second movement and in the finale, where it comes fully into the open.
The Symphony No. 10 in E minor, Op. 93, was premiered on 17 December 1953, with Yevgeny Mravinsky conducting the Leningrad Philharmonic. The work prompted debate about the nature of symphonism and symphonic form itself. Contemporary critics faulted the work for lacking the sense of formal completeness expected of a cyclical symphony. Shostakovich responded that, in his view, the movements of a symphony should not be judged merely as parts of a larger whole, but rather as “independent large-scale works. Each movement ... must possess its own musical and dramatic development.” The composerʼs statement illustrates the situation in which he found himself: subjected to constant ideological pressure that did not abate even after the dictatorʼs death. “If the Tenth Symphony is criticized for lacking formal completeness, the criticism is justified”, Shostakovich admitted. “The finale is dominated by rapid, energetic themes; perhaps a more lyrical theme somewhere in the middle or towards the end would have been desirable. [...] Should I revise the finale or write a new one? Perhaps I shall one day, but not now. I have thought the work through, lived with it, and at present I could not return to it.” Opportunism? Not at all. Shostakovich remained convinced of the workʼs quality, and he never changed a single note.
Yevgeny Mravinsky and the Leningrad Philharmonic performed the Tenth Symphony on 3 June 1955 at the Prague Spring Festival, but the work had been given its Prague premiere during the festival’s previous season on 19 May 1954 with Franz Konwitschny conducting the Leipzig Gewandhaus Orchestra.